Every big sport has its annual video game series, though some are definitely better than others. MLB The Show has stood out as one of the most consistent and dependable sports game franchises out there, with many of its editions receiving rave reviews and even some achieving high critical acclaim. The latest title, MLB The Show 25, continues this legacy, providing yet another well-crafted entry. While it may not represent a groundbreaking shift in the baseball sim genre, it certainly delivers a refined and comprehensive gaming experience.
The heart of MLB The Show 25 is built upon the excellent foundation San Diego Studio has perfected over the years. It’s truly hard to envision a baseball simulation that could play much smoother than this one. The game offers players a plethora of options to customize their experience exactly how they want to play. Whether you’re just looking to enjoy a laid-back baseball game or you’re a hardcore fan craving realism, MLB The Show 25 has you covered. Plus, with dynamic difficulty settings, the game can automatically adjust according to your skill level, ensuring an optimized playing experience.
There’s plenty of room for personal preference when it comes to controls in MLB The Show 25. Opt for the traditional button-based batting or switch to the stick-flick mechanism that The Show has popularized. Essentially, the game offers extensive customization options that allow players to tailor their gameplay precisely. Personally, I experimented with various control schemes, ultimately settling on stick input for batting while relying on the dynamic difficulty setting throughout most of my play sessions.
Once players have found their groove, MLB The Show 25 opens the doors to a plethora of game modes packed with content to explore. Loyal fans will likely gravitate towards their favorite modes, and they can feel confident knowing these beloved features return as strong as ever.
Since its 2006 inception, the signature Road to the Show mode has drawn players in as they guide a single character from humble beginnings to potential baseball superstardom. MLB The Show 25 enhances this journey by starting players off in high school. This allows fans to follow their character’s rise to fame, immersing them deeper into their career’s narrative.
Customization is king in MLB The Show 25’s Road to the Show, from your character’s gender and field positions to their initial stats. The game provides a comprehensive suite for personalizing your baseball avatar, even including face-scan technology if you fancy seeing yourself in the game. As with any face-scan feature, expect some hilarious misfires, but with perseverance, you should be able to create a likeness you’re happy with.
The integration of RPG elements in MLB The Show 25 allows for further depth. Players encounter dialogue options, equip gear for stat enhancements, and engage with a leveling system. XP is awarded for positive gameplay actions, and bonus XP or tokens can be earned by completing challenges. Road to the Show continues to be a rich and rewarding experience, even if it stumbles with its lack of voice acting and occasionally cheesy dialogue. Yet, the focus remains squarely on the gameplay — which is thrilling — and the introduction of a new first-person perspective adds an intriguing twist, despite my preference for the traditional view.
While Road to the Show is expansive, it’s merely the beginning. Another major time sink for players is Diamond Dynasty, a staple trading card mode in sports games today. Here, the focus is on gathering player cards to assemble an unbeatable team. This year, MLB The Show 25 improves accessibility by removing the constraint of seasonal play, an enhancement I appreciate even though microtransaction-heavy modes aren’t my favorite. However, MLB The Show historically handles these aspects less offensively than other games, a trend that continues in this edition.
Diamond Quest is a fresh new addition to MLB The Show 25’s Diamond Dynasty, adding a clever roguelike element where players roll dice to navigate a board, facing challenges for rewards while dodging penalties. This inventive spin should captivate fans seeking something new from an already robust lineup.
Of course, for those who prefer focusing purely on the baseball action, MLB The Show 25 accommodates with standard games against AI, local multiplayer, and online multiplayer modes. The core gameplay remains stellar, maintaining its position as the pinnacle of baseball simulation — a notable advantage, given its status as the sole player in its genre.
Despite these positives, some might feel there’s room for improvement. MLB The Show 25 lacks a groundbreaking new feature that would make it indispensable for fans already immersed in previous versions. The game feels more incremental than revolutionary, aligning with previous editions without making major strides forward. While its visual presentation impresses with realistic details like lighting and the grit of the field, its graphical improvements aren’t groundbreaking. The game bypassed last-gen consoles, yet its graphics seem achievable on older systems, as evidenced by occasional graphical quirks like clipping and uninspired stadium backgrounds.
Annual sports games inevitably have releases focusing more on refining past concepts rather than daring innovations, and MLB The Show 25 finds itself in this category. Still, nearly everything here is executed well enough to satisfy baseball enthusiasts with rich content and engaging gameplay. While those seeking novelty might feel underwhelmed, it’s hard to fault a game that consistently delivers such a solid experience year after year.
